This resource will help you design flexible instruction, including incorporation of synchronous and asynchronous online components into your on-campus, in-person classes. This type of flexible instruction helps to guide students towards independent learning and maintain instructional continuity when students cannot make it to classes for a variety of reasons.
Note:
Offerings that promote simultaneous on-campus and remote instruction could be facilitated in academic units that have the infrastructure to do so.
Pre-Planning Flexible Instruction
Designing a course that includes more flexibility for students is challenging and to do it well requires upfront planning. Below are some considerations:
- Learning Outcomes: Provide flexibility in how learning outcomes can be met effectively by all students. This will allow you to vary assessments, provide choice, and engage students in same or equivalent learning activities (Beatty, 2019). For further information on writing learning outcomes, see Learning Outcomes: Construction.
- Instructional Approach: Consider a ‘flipped classroom’ instructional approach when presenting a large amount of content (Lewis & Hesson, 2021). It can help you prepare more engaging synchronous classes and at the same time build required resources and activities that can be shared with students who cannot make it to class for a variety of reasons. See these resources:
- Assessment: Look for evidence of learning over time by providing multiple opportunities to demonstrate learning and moving some assessments online. For suggestions, see Moving Assessment to Remote Learning Within Brightspace, and check out list of alternative assessments for remote teaching, along with rubrics at York University.
- Syllabus: Update your syllabus to reflect the learning environment. For example, include:
- a statement on course format and communication. (see example below)
- class guidelines on participation expectations, such as netiquette for communicating online.
- a course schedule that outlines the learning activities and assessments, along with the time slots for participating in synchronous sessions and time frame/due dates for completing asynchronous activities.
Example of a Format and Communication Statement
- Learning Activities: Select activities that are engaging and can be completed asynchronously and synchronously. See ‘Active Learning While Physically Distancing, Louisiana State University’ for suggestive activities for different instructional approaches.
- Course Resources: Make resources accessible to all students. See Course Content and Instruction web page for suggestions on recording lectures, distributing content, accessibility guidelines, and privacy considerations.
- Brightspace: Design your course in Brightspace to guide student learning and your instruction. For information on using the tools and features, see CITL’s Brightspace How-To-Guides and Tutorials.
- Quality Design Guidelines: To determine if you have included the critical and recommended elements in your course for students to succeed, use the CITL Quality Course Design Rubric as a guide.
Strategies for Facilitating Asynchronous Learning
Strategies to help facilitate asynchronous learning so students feel more engaged in their learning experience include:
- Weekly Structure: Create a consistent, clear structure in Brightspace for each week.
View an example of a weekly structure
Example of a Consistent, Clear Weekly Structure
Week 3 Overview
This week we will review how students learn and look at how the different learning theories can influence how you teach and the instructional resources and technology you use. A learning-centered approach to instruction will be discussed.
Learning Outcomes
After completing the readings and learning activities for this week, you will be able to:
- discuss how different learning theories can influence the design of instruction;
- identify examples of appropriate assessments, instructional strategies, and resources for each of the four major learning perspectives; and
- make decisions on the best media and technology to use for specific instructional situations.
Tasks
Adapted from Phillips P. (2018). ED3801: Educational Media. Course Notes.
- Adding Context: Explain purpose of resources uploaded to Brightspace and provide detailed directions for assignments and activities. For further information and examples, review Adding Context section in A Guide for Designing Online Learning & Increasing Instructional Use of Brightspace.
- Screencasts: Use screencasts to demonstrate procedures and solutions to problems (Bronkey, 2015). Check out Screenpal.
- Automatic Feedback: Use Brightspace Quizzes tool or H5P Memorial Resources Environment to create activities that provide instance feedback.
- Exams: Consider using an exam wrapper for students to reflect on their performance on an exam (Carnegie Mellon University, n.d.).
- Discussions: Use Brightspace discussion tool to engage students asynchronously. Students can share documents and record audio and video postings. Review these 10 tips to help you design effective online discussions (Simon, 2018).
- Group Assignments: Have students work together on small, low-stake group assignments that may lead to producing an authentic project due at end of course (Lewis & Hesson, 2021). For suggestions on how to effectively facilitate group work, view the University at Buffalo Center for Educational Innovation (CEI) Group Work website.
- Peer Assessments: Have students do peer reviews/assessments within a group discussion forum or consider using the video assignment tool or peerScholar.
- Sense of Community: Establish social interaction and build a sense of community. For ideas, view CITL’s resource on Creating a Community in Your Remote Course.
- Updates & Reminders: Use the Brightspace announcement tool to post updates and reminders of tutorials, office hours, and assignment due dates.
- Office Hours: Hold office hours and tutorials online using Webex or Online Rooms.
Other Brightspace Tools/Features to Consider
- Use Manage Files tool to upload or copy a number of files at once from your computer to your course site.
- Use Assignments tool to retrieve and track assignment submissions. Assignments are date stamped when submitted.
- Save time grading using the Assignments tool feedback options. You can annotate the submission file, record feedback in a text box, attach additional files, or record audio or video feedback. Also, save drafts as you mark and publish when all are graded.
- Use the Rubrics tool to create a rubric and link it to a graded assignment, including a discussion topic. Rubrics can be copied and used in multiple course sites.
- Use the Grades tool to create a gradebook for all items you are evaluating students on. Associate a grade item with any quiz, discussion activity, or assignments folder, so grades are automatically entered and a final grade calculated.
- Use the Class Progress tool to see the overall progress of a student. This includes seeing if students have logged in to course, viewed a topic page, participated in discussions, submitted assignments, or completed quizzes.
- Turn on completion tracking so students can monitor their own progress. Depending on the completion method selected, content pages students view will be automatically marked as completed or students can manually mark the page as completed when viewed.
- Use Video Note tool to create recordings with your webcam and insert them directly on a content page.
- Use the Brightspace Editor’s ‘Insert stuff’ option to embed or link to a video note or a resource created within the H5P Memorial Resources Environment.
- Organize and manage week-specific course items using the Checklist tool.
- Use notifications to keep up-to-date on with course activities.
- Use the Calendar tool to post due dates and link to descriptions of activities and assessment content pages.
Strategies for Facilitating Online Synchronous Classes
The following strategies contribute to the success of facilitating and supporting student learning in scheduled online synchronous class meetings.
Before Session
- Prepare an instructional lesson plan or outline/agenda for each synchronous class session (Kelly, 2020) and upload to Brightspace.
- Strategies for Effective Lesson Planning from the University of Michigan.
- HyFlex Sample Lesson from Columbia University’s School of Professional Studies
View an Example of a Weekly Outline / Agenda
- Arrange a demonstration of the classroom and online video conferencing technology. Determine what you are responsible for in relation to equipment operation, troubleshooting, and how best to facilitate the session. Visit CITL’s website for ‘How to Guides’ for using classroom equipment.
- Establish a general class structure and format — how you want to facilitate your classroom (i.e., asking questions, use of camera, online netiquette, and technical issues).
- Do a ‘practice run’.
- Upload resources used in the session to Brightspace ahead of time. This will save time in class and allow students to prepare for class, including accessing resources when requiring accommodations (CAST, n.d; Marquart, et al., 2018).
- For individual, peer or small group activities, display clear directions (i.e., on slide, whiteboard, Google doc) as to what you want students to do (Bergstrom, 2020).
During Session
Best Practices for Facilitating Synchronous Classes
- At the beginning of class, follow up on activities completed online from previous class.
- To maintain flow of session and encourage participation from students, build in more formal breaks for question and answer (Kelly, 2019).
- If teaching remote and in-person students at same time, rotate questions between both groups (Bergstrom, 2020).
- If an online chat is used, pause class periodically for TA or student assigned to share questions and comments in chat (Dexter & Taylor, 2021).
- Use online polling tools, such as Mentimeter, to solicit feedback from all students (Dexter & Taylor, 2021).
- Use Google docs, slides, spreadsheets or fillable PDF documents for students to record notes or collaborate on a document.
- Use online discussion forums in Brightspace to continue discussion after class.
- Summarize key points at the end.
Review additional Best Practices for Video Conferencing on CITL’s website.
Group Work Strategies
- Provide clear directions on a PowerPoint slide or Google doc.
- Limit group interactions to 10 minutes or less (Lewis & Hesson, 2021).
- For physical distancing measures, reduce class group sizes to two or three (Lewis & Hesson, 2021).
- Have students take the lead to present their group summary.
- Ask a student participating online and an in-person student with a computer to meet in an online breakout room (Lewis & Hesson, 2021).
- Assign a Google slide to any group participating online so you can see the interaction taking place, notes they are capturing, and whether additional or less time is needed (Bergstrom, 2020).
Web Conferencing Features and Uses
Feature or Tool | Educational Uses for Students and Instructor |
---|---|
Text Chat | Share links to resources used (i.e., websites, videos, audio clips, images) Upload and share a file (i.e., PDF) Save or copy text chat for review later |
Share Screen/Desktop/Program | Demonstrate an application View or refer students to resource on Internet Present a concept or student presentation |
Breakout Rooms | Collaborative work Discussion Small group activity |
Poll | Pre and post assessment Stimulate discussion and debates Provide choice Feedback |
Whiteboard & Annotation Tools | Display slides Solve a problem Brainstorming Drawing activities Share and annotate other documents, images, etc. |
Emoticons/Reactions | Use ‘Raise Hands’ to ask a question Obtain and give instant feedback (i.e., applause, thumbs up, confused) |
Presenter | Make a participant presenter (i.e., student presentations, debates, manage slides ) |
Share webcam/video | Get to know each other Demonstrate a procedure Role playing |
Copy External Link | Invite a guest speaker |
Adapted from CAST (n.d.) UDL On Campus, http://udloncampus.cast.org/page/media_webcast
After Session
- Let students know when and where the recording is available in Brightspace.
- Add the summary of class meeting to Brightspace.
- Remind students to complete the follow-up self assessment in Brightspace (Elkhoury & Frake-Mistak, 2021).
Some Examples of Flexible Instruction
See this resource at the University of Waterloo for examples of blended learning in courses.
References
- Alternative assessments for remote teaching (n.d.). Toronto, CA: York University. Retrieved from: https://www.yorku.ca/teachingcommons/wp-content/uploads/sites/38/2021/06/Alternative-Assessments-for-Remote-Teaching.docx.pdf
- Bergstrom, M. (2020, November 25). Teaching hyFlex: It’s a genre problem. Faculty Focus: Higher Ed Teaching Strategies from Magna Publications. Retrieved from: https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/online-education/teaching-hyflex-its-a-genre-problem/
- CAST (n.d.). UDL ON CAMPUS: Universal Design for Learning in Higher Education. Retrieved from: http://udloncampus.cast.org/page/media_webcast
- Dexter, C., & Taylor, Z. (2021, August 23). The importance of listening to student learning. Faculty Focus: Higher Ed Teaching Strategies from Magna Publications. Retrieved from: https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/online-education/online-course-delivery-and-instruction/the-importance-of-listening-to-student-learning/
- Elkhoury, E. & Frake-Mistak, M. (2021). HyFlex course design. Toronto, ON: York University. Retrieved from: https://www.yorku.ca/teachingcommons/wp-content/uploads/sites/38/2021/07/Hyflex-Course-Design-.pdf
- Kelly, K. (2020, May 7). COVID-19 planning for fall 2020: A closer look at Hybrid-Flexible course design. PhiIonEDTech. Retrieved from: https://philonedtech.com/covid-19-planning-for-fall-2020-a-closer-look-at-hybrid-flexible-course-design/
- Lewis, K. D., & Hesson, N. (2021, April 16). Adapting group activities for COVID to ignite student engagement. Faculty Focus: Higher Ed Teaching Strategies from Magna Publications . Retrieved from: https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/effective-classroom-management/adapting-group-activities-for-covid-to-ignite-student-engagement/
- Marquart, M., Englisher, M., Tokieda, K., Samuel, V., Standlee, J., & Telfair-Garcia, A. (2018). Can online students be fully integrated into residential courses via web conferencing? Lessons learned from two pilot courses at Columbia University. Workshop presented at the Online Learning Consortium Accelerate Conference, Orlando, FL. Retrieved from: https://academiccommons.columbia.edu/doi/10.7916/D8M91SK7
- Milkova, S. (n.d.). Center for Research on Learning & Teaching. Strategies for effective lesson planning. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan. Retrieved from: https://crlt.umich.edu/gsis/p2_5
- School of Professional Studies (n.d.). HyFlex: Sample lesson. New York: NY: Columbia University. Retrieved from: https://academicaffairs.sps.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/content/Sample%20Class%20Session.pdf
- Bronkey, K. (2015). Rethinking direct instruction in online learning. Faculty Focus: Higher Ed Teaching Strategies from Magna Publications. Retrieved from: https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/online-education/rethinking-direct-instruction-in-online-learning/
- Eberly Center (n.d.). Exam wrappers. Pittsburgh, PA: Carnegie Mellon University. Retrieved from: https://www.cmu.edu/teaching/designteach/teach/examwrappers/
- Lewis, K. D., & Hesson, N. (2021, April 16). Adapting group activities for COVID to ignite student engagement. Faculty Focus: Higher Ed Teaching Strategies from Magna Publications. Retrieved from: https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/effective-classroom-management/adapting-group-activities-for-covid-to-ignite-student-engagement/
- Simon, E. (2018, November 21). 10 tips for effective online discussions. EDUCAUSE Review. Retrieved from: https://er.educause.edu/blogs/2018/11/10-tips-for-effective-online-discussions
- Office of Curriculum, Assessment and Teaching Transformation (2021). Group work. Buffalo: NY: University of Buffalo. Retrieved from: http://www.buffalo.edu/catt/develop/teach/group-work.html
- Alternative assessments for remote teaching (n.d.). Toronto, ON: York University. Retrieved from: https://www.yorku.ca/teachingcommons/wp-content/uploads/sites/38/2021/06/Alternative-Assessments-for-Remote-Teaching.docx.pdf
- Beatty, B.J. (2019). Hybrid-Flexible course design: Implementing student-directed hybrid classes. EdTech Books. Retrieved from: https://edtechbooks.org/hyflex/
- Center for Teaching and Learning (n.d.). How do you flip a class? Austin, TX: University of Texas at Austin. Retrieved from: https://ctl.utexas.edu/how-to-flip
- Honeycutt, B. (2013, March 25). Looking for ‘flippable’ moments in your class. Faculty Focus: Higher Ed Teaching Strategies from Magna Publications. Retrieved from: https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/blended-flipped-learning/looking-for-flippable-moments-in-your-class/
- Lewis, K. D., & Hesson, N. (2021, April 16). Adapting group activities for COVID to ignite student engagement. Faculty Focus: Higher Ed Teaching Strategies from Magna Publications. Retrieved from: https://www.facultyfocus.com/articles/effective-classroom-management/adapting-group-activities-for-covid-to-ignite-student-engagement/
- Teaching tools: Active learning while physically distancing (2020). Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University. Retrieved from: https://docs.google.com/document/d/15ZtTu2pmQRU_eC3gMccVhVwDR57PDs4uxlMB7Bs1os8/edit
Originally Published: October 13, 2021
Last Updated: September 18, 2024